X-MEN ORIGINS: WOLVERINE is not worth paying for

Posted by Michael Edwards on April 28, 2009 – 9:46 am | 12 comments

I haven’t been this disappointed by a film since the new Indiana Jones, and my disappointment provoked so much fury then that I’m a little bit nervous about venting my frustration about X-Men Origins: Wolverine. Nonetheless, so lame was this woeful attempt to milk a franchise that I can’t contain myself: so here goes…

x-men_origins_wolverine_movie_image_hugh_jackman

Wasn’t Wolverine (Hugh Jackman) supposed to be a short, gruff, angry, violent killer who goes psycho a lot and stabs people? I know he’s a good guy, and his character is a bit deeper than just that, but I’m sure he was once a soldier who revelled in his talent at slaughter? Nobody seems to have told director Gavin Hood and credited writer David Benioff. Between them they seem to think that he’s a big handsome fella, who’s loving, jovial and very very vulnerable. Plus he walks around topless a lot. I mean A LOT. And when the lust for vengeance pulses through his veins, he seems to calm down and act normally again pretty fucking quickly.

Rather than explain how Wolverine became who he is in the original trilogy, XMO just reduces everything to a single story of deceit centring on the evil plans of Colonel Striker (Danny Huston) and a ‘warring brothers’ story between Wolverine and Sabretooth (Liev Schrieber). Essentially, it seems that these guys think that he is not a character, a product of the way he was treated as a mutant and the horrors he has experienced as a result, he is just a malleable plot tool to be twisted to fit around a bunch of marketable action sequences and gratuitous topless scenes. And that sucks.

x-men-review-2

Logan will one minute be a hard-nosed killer, and then suddenly he’ll drop his weapons and take the moral high-ground in a move clearly devised by edgy execs pandering to the pervading liberal atmosphere among audiences at the moment. This new, flaky character is played off against Sabretooth who embraces his destructive talents with a fervour that should be equally strong in his brother. By reducing the bloodthirsty side of Logan his quest for revenge just doesn’t work properly.

But the needless modification go much further, even the defining scenes look as if they’ve been excessively tinkered with. There is no flow at all. I could almost hear the director’s instructions in every scene. Wolverine runs though the forest, “You’re frightened, confused, you’ve been a civilian too long, good.. good. CUT” Next scene: “OK you’ve seen the body, you’re hurting, you’re conflicted, this one’s big! Cue awful Hollywood archetypes number four, and ACTION!”, Logan: “No, no…” cut to overhead shot, “NOOOOOOOOO!”. It’s the same in the big finale, disjointed moments that are supposed to develop the tortured character that Logan becomes just look like a clunky collection of sickeningly contrived and poorly executed bullshit.

But what’s really a kick in the balls is that the action sequences these lame scenes prop up aren’t even good! Pitiful template chases are followed by distinctly ordinary fight scenes that are supported by CGI so bad that I was tempted to walk up to the screen with a marker pen and touch up the edges on Wolverines adamantium claws. And the fight with Deadpool (Ryan Reynolds) that’s crowbarred in at the end finishes almost laughably.

However, worse than the disappointing action sequences and the poor storytelling was the obvious gearing of the film to make room for more franchise-expanding films. Characters are introduced in as simple and unfulfilling ways as you might expect from a re-boot, they amount to little more than a series of mini-trailers for their appearances in later films pepper the story.

Sure Gambit (Taylor Kitsch) and Deadpool have their parts to play, but their introductions are so insubstantial and superflous that could easily have been forsaken for some much needed (and deserved) substance in the stories that supposedly define Wolverine and Sabretooth.

opjdopjopjo

Comic book fans would be particularly disappointed by the introduction of long-time favourite Gambit: a mediocre attempt at a stylised scene which saw him pitted against Wolverine and real life poker pro Daniel Negraneau in a game of Texas Hold’em. Not quite what we have been waiting for with three movies.

The nail in the coffin of the movie comes, fittingly, at the end. The justification for Logan’s memory loss is as crappy and unimaginative as it is badly shot. And if that wasn’t bad enough, a scene was tagged on at the end of the credits that was clearly only added to lure those naughty few who nabbed the download into some paying seats. It’s not worth the wait at all. A bit like the whole movie actually…

12 Comments

The Glove on April 28, 2009 at 11:02 am

Shit ,we comic book fans hate to see reviews like this, but hey, it’s only one dudes opinion right!?

Matt Holmes on April 28, 2009 at 11:15 am

I indeed remember that Indiana Jones review, the first negative piece I had read on Spielberg and Lucas’ flick. I gulped at how much you hated the review, hoping that you were wrong, but I I just kinda new you wouldn’t be.

Reality kicked in when I read your review and I realised that INDY IV wouldn’t be the movie we had waited 18 years to see. And it wasn’t.

David on April 28, 2009 at 11:34 am

Clap…Clap…clap – I applaud you for telling it like it was. Although it would have been good to at least give it credit for it’s few high moments such as Ryan Reynold’s wit as Wade/Deadpool in the opening sequence.

This may entertain the movie goer that never picked up a comic in their life to some extent it, it was bound to be a disappointment to the avid follower. The Wolverine story could be a trilogy of Lord of the Rings proportions by itself. Instead of such an epic we are left with a predictable, unsatisfying movie which focussed more on showing of Hugh Jackman’s body than the ferocious animalistic nature of wolverine. He was a violent wild killer – an anti-hero that Riddick in pitch black could only dream of being and in the movie he is reduced a teddy bear.

mr.bucket on April 28, 2009 at 1:31 pm

crap now im confused the first review said it was good and now its bad.argggg i guess i just go see it myself and find out.

Ray on April 28, 2009 at 1:37 pm

From what I understand, the workprint I saw is pretty much the final product with updated special effects. Which is a shame, because that workprint has promise, but, as I mentioned in my review of it, the finale is clumsy and some of the characters are not worked in properly (like Gambit). There is a decent film in here, and there are parts of this film I like very much. But it needed some work … I guess the reshoots weren’t as extensive as I thought.

Vincent B. Gorce on April 28, 2009 at 1:39 pm

I agree about the lack of animosity and the hollywood cliches shots.
I really felt let down by the absence of background story for the other mutants and the stupid ending of deadpool(was he supposed to die anyway?)
the arrival of Xavier was oh so predictible, and yes…once again,Wolverine is not angry enough!!!
the movie will appeal to non fans because it is typical hollywood entertainement…Look at the figures for Indy IV!!!
Great review mate, keep up the good work!

Toby on April 28, 2009 at 2:29 pm

“…pervading liberal atmosphere…”

you think liberals are more conservative than conservatives?

Michael Edwards on April 28, 2009 at 3:08 pm

@ Toby: oddly, sometimes, yes. But that’s another matter. In the review I just meant that because people have gone anti war (hurrah!) the studio execs have decided that to be popular films can’t make violence cool at the moment (Boooo!).

MDOC on April 28, 2009 at 5:42 pm

Wolverine sucked. The story is just not interesting or worthy really. Wolverine should have been “Taken” with Wolverine. Set him up, give him a reason for revenge, turn him into Weapon X and unleash him. Instead what do we have? The first 5 minutes were almost interesting, the “special team” was weak. The Gambit parts were boring and the Blob fight was painfully stupid. I live for these comic book movies but the Blob scene almost made me leave. The film almost gets interesting for a moment at the end but the double agent dead girlfriend angle was laughable.
I never found Sabertooth to be an interesting enough character to justify trashing the continuity of X-Men 1. Summer is off to a bad start and the once interesting X franchise is in shambles.

Despacio on April 29, 2009 at 8:37 am

I have to apologize Mr. Edwards from jumping on you for your one star review of Indy IV a year ago. There was just no way Spielberg, Ford, and Lucas could screw up Indy after all those years of getting that project off the ground.

Sure enough, that movie was awful, though maybe not one star awful, but awful enough I have yet to see it a second time out of disgust.

As for Wolverine, I can’t believe Fox lied about the final cut being very different from the work print. Still I have two free tickets and I hope to enjoy Wolverine as mindless summer entertainment, classic film or not.

Michael Edwards on April 29, 2009 at 11:30 am

Thanks Despacio! You’re probably right about it not being one-star awful, it might get two for the couple of cool old-school moments. The rating was driven down by my disgust at the flagrant franchise milking… anyhow, water under the bridge now.

As to Wolverine, enjoy Ryan Reynolds when he’s on-screen for his short scenes: he’s the best bit there! There are one or two funny parts too. But I won’t spoil those.

entertainmenttodayandbeyond on April 29, 2009 at 5:09 pm

To this day I’l never understand how Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Cystal skull has 77% positive rating on Rotten tomatoes. What a massive disappointment. Even though there are 5 positive reviews on Rotten tomatoes for Wolverine the fact that Fox has an embargo on U.S critics until 48 hr before its release tells you they don’t have confidence that the majority will give it a thumbs up!

chuck

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

Register or Login to your account and this info is automatically added!

*
*