Review – TERMINATOR: SALVATION

Posted by Ray DeRousse on May 21, 2009 – 9:10 am | 13 comments

Like one of its unstoppable robots, the TERMINATOR series continues to chase after its prey: the almighty dollar. The first film in the series was the complete package, a sleek and deadly time travel tale that ends on a tidy and final note. Creator/director James Cameron brought the series back to life in 1991, though, with a few new wrinkles, some very special effects, and lots of ultra-action – but there wasn’t much of a story to tell. the third film had even less on its mind, reducing the iconic Terminator franchise to a series of action set pieces.

Now we have a fourth film in the franchise. It is a gritty, vicious, and ultimately empty experience.

Christian Bale stars as John Connor, the grown-up version of the bratty kid in JUDGMENT DAY. Connor has taken his place as the spiritual leader of the Resistance, largely due to the recording left by his mother that tell the stories related to her by Kyle Reese from the first film. Connor is preparing his ragged troops for a final assault against the Skynet control compound utilizing a signal that will disable the machines.

But this is also a movie about a man named Marcus (Sam Worthington), a convicted criminal who manages to cheat death thanks to Cyberdyne technology. Dazed and confused in this post-Judgment Day world, Marcus goes in search of Skynet in the hopes of finding answers. Eventually, Marcus and Connor team up to try and defeat the machines.

First of all, the technical effects are excellent and, in some instances, breathtaking. The sound effects department had better start preparing Oscar speeches, because I thought the sound design was spectacular. Most of the CGI works very well in this film as well, which are combined deftly with some excellent practical effects. Every dollar is showing onscreen.

Where the movie falters is with the script and the cast. First of all, the script lacks a propulsive drive toward a third act climax. The motivations of each character are all over the place. One minute Connor is suspicious of Marcus, and then in the next he’s making plans with him. Particularly confusing is Marcus’ motivation to go to Skynet. How exactly does he know he needs to go there? Why does he think the answers are there? On what is he seeking revenge?

The script has serious character problems as well. Connor is reduced to a barking, brooding monotony of wartime cliches. Several other characters are thinly sketched references to other films. For example, the little girl here is reminiscent of Newt from ALIENS, except without her charm or story depth. Other characters follow similar fates. Anton Yelchin’s Kyle Reese is the typical “young man who wants to be a leader” character we have seen in countless other films.

My other complaint about the script is the fact that it doesn’t really have an ending. By the time the film is finished, you realize you’ve been duped. You just sat through a film that didn’t really matter at all. Connor doesn’t really accomplish anything, and none of the actual story about the war has only just begun. It’s a very frustrating aspect to this movie.

The performances are generally pretty bad overall. Worthington and Yelchin by far do the best work here; Worthington steals the movie from Bale with a fairly charismatic performance that infuses his poorly written character with just enough actual emotion to remain believable. Yelchin has almost nothing substantial to use from the script, but he manages to give his Reese some substance anyway.

Bale is awful, though. All growling and grumbling in that low-pitched whisper of his, Bale has become a caricature of himself. While watching the film, I thought that I’d be happy to never watch him act again. To quote the man himself, “it’s fucking distracting” to watch him repeat the same tone of voice in every performance. Does he have anything else to offer anymore?

The other truly bad performance comes from the infamous Helena Bonham Carter, who plays a scientist with Cyberdyne who eventually becomes the face of Skynet. The idea is ludicrous enough, basically taking a forgettable page out of SUPERMAN 3’s horrible robot lady. But then you cast Carter in the role, and she does her usual lip-twitching, wide-eyed psychopath routine. I would say that I haven’t liked a single performance from her since MERLIN so long ago, and even that was over-the-top. It’s a terribly distracting performance that induces laughter.

And one other point – Arnold makes an appearance here that is truly breathtaking. The CGI artists who made it possible should all be commended for that stunning entrance.

Director McG does a good job of keeping the action tight and punishing. There are several excellent action beats in this film, and all of them are handled well. The film has a washed-out look similar to SAVING PRIVATE RYAN, and McG does a masterful job of putting the audience right in the thick of the action. Some of this film is simply not his fault; his direction is ankled time and again by a poorly designed script.

The film ends on a half note, basically warming us up for the inevitable part two of a new trilogy. Unfortunately, part one is less than satisfying. Perhaps the next time they approach one of these films, they should worry more about telling one cohesive story, rather than spend their time counting the money they will make from their lucrative and obligatory trilogies.

I, for one, wouldn’t mind this series being terminated.

13 Comments

AnthonyB14 on May 21, 2009 at 12:06 pm

God, I knew this was gonna happen. Michael Ferris and John Brancato are awfull scripters, even John Nolan couldn’t salvage their script. They should get the Wachowski Bros or Tim Burton for the next one!

Ray on May 21, 2009 at 1:34 pm

@ anthony – Must there be another one??

Nico on May 21, 2009 at 3:02 pm

@ Ray… for what i’ve read NO! but… if there is a “trilogy” behind this new chapter… and all based in what i read above, they need to start thinking in new writers for the script… I dunno if Burton will do the job… but certainly the Wachowski brothers will do!
Hey! there is always an unknown writer with hunger for recognition, that should work! :D

Ricky on May 21, 2009 at 10:03 pm

I must confess I had great hopes from this film but folks the truth is that it really sucks big time. Even as god damn entertainment film.

Simon Gallagher on May 22, 2009 at 12:31 am

Ray, man! You didnt enjoy Helena Bonham-Carter in FIGHT CLUB? “I havent been fucked like that since grade-school?”/”I want to have your abortion”? Both alternatives to the line were irresistible but her delivery was the real killer!

Her accent might be a bit off, but she was damn good in that film. And she’s the perfect casting choice for Bellatrix Lestrange, no matter what you think of the books or films.

VideoRaider on May 22, 2009 at 7:56 am

So the fact that Ray has allready seen it means he is a Yankee? Interesting.

Anyways…I am huge Terminator fan. Huge, huge, huge. I saw T2 in the cinema. I was 8 – but luckily my older sister helped me to get in. And the film totally blew me away. Totally.

So I am really looking forward to T4 but all the negative reviews make me kinda nervous…

TONY on May 25, 2009 at 1:54 am

Cant wait to see this flick. I personally loved T2.
Im just counting on John Conner being a bad ass this time around.
Thats the one thing missing from the franchise.

cambion on May 25, 2009 at 11:08 pm

Terminator 2 was the one that was low on story!?

T1, while totally awesome, was basically just a big ’80’s action movie with a cool plot device. I really think the second one was superior in every way – acting, script, characterization, plot, and action. In fact, it’s the film Cameron wanted to make, but the technology wasn’t there yet. The series should have ended there.

KC on May 26, 2009 at 2:22 am

Saw the new Terminator over the weekend. Its a very pretty movie effects wise. The story as Ray said, is pretty much non-existant. Its sad to see what they have turned Connor into. Honestly, I don’t blame Bale for any of this. I blame the script first off because it is completely awful in every way possible and I blame McG as the director for not bringing something better out of him. THe director is supposed to direct the actors. If he’s too much of a pussy to tell Bale not to use that damn voice, he shouldn’t be directing.

Ray on May 26, 2009 at 3:45 am

@ KC – Um, you heard Bale’s rant, didn’t you?? I for one can see why McG chickened out LOL.

Unlike you, however, I do blame Bale for giving that performance; it lacks a believable scope and becomes a joke. But Bale was a good initial pick for the role, but imagine what someone with more range – let’s say an Edward Norton – could have done with the role. Bale was picked because he was the “it” guy of the moment, but I thought he was horribly one-note and boring. That “you’re not going to kill me speech” was laughable.

MDOC on May 27, 2009 at 2:40 am

Good review, I liked parts of Terminator:Salvation but it just didn’t come together and the ending was an insult to anyone that knows anything about medicine. I still hope they make more.

Parker on May 30, 2009 at 5:05 pm

I enjoyed it for what it was. Sam Worthington did a great job and I hope to see him in a lot more stuff. Although, I do think the worst line of the movie was Marcus Wright in jail at the beginning talking to cancer doctor Carter…”So that’s what death tastes like”. I also enjoyed Yelchin and Bloodgood’s performances. I really like Christian Bale, but there’s no getting around it, this is the worst acting job he has ever done, period.

TONY on May 30, 2009 at 8:42 pm

WOW. what a turd!
As I begin to post this comment, nothing positive comes to mind as I think back on this film. LAME, LAME, LAME! First off, Bale is awful. Conner talks about the resistance and how important is to stay alive, yet I’m not to sure if Conner is human or machine. Conner does make me laugh when he keeps hitting up his dead mom’s cassette tapes for advice. I mean how is it Marcus Wright is the one who conveys more human emotion than the majority of the cast. Come on, he’s a convicted murder who happens to be a terminator!
It’s now quite obvious why Josh Brolin turned the Marcus Wright role down. Because he saw this fucking train wreak a mile away.
Not sure if many of you noticed this, but why in the fuck is COMMON wearing designer fucking sunglasses at the end of the film, in the middle of the night, while trying to evacuate humans in the middle of gun fire and chaos? WTF!
But on a final note. I don’t even blame douche bag director MCG.
I have one word for you guys.
CATWOMAN!
That right ladies and gentlemen, the writers (John D. Brancato & Michael Farris) of TERMINATOR SALVATION, also brought you the award winning screen play CATWOMAN. What fucking shit. I need to take another shower.
Enough said.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0327554/fullcredits#writers

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

Register or Login to your account and this info is automatically added!

*
*