Viewing the 'Jon-Favreau' Category

Marvel & Favreau come to a deal for IRON MAN 2

Jesus, when you see the disaster job Peter Berg and Louis Letterier have done with The Incredible Hulk and Hancock this Summer… two movies which won’t perform anywhere near as well at the box office if sequels are (and it’s certainly not guaranteed) greenlit then it’s unsurprising that Marvel have quickly agreed to pay Jon Favreau’s slightly increased wage demands over Iron Man 2.

And after a origin film which has grossed over $550 million worldwide and a series which will live for a long time and make several more millions for them, you can hardly say he hasn’t deserved it.

072807_marvel4.jpg

The news comes from Nikki Finke

It’s not officially announced yet, but I’m told that Marvel Studios and Iron Man director Jon Favreau have reached a deal for him to helm the sequel, due out in 2010.

Jon Favreau did a quite wonderful job with Iron Man and unlike Letterier and Berg - here is a guy who loves this genre, completely gets the Tony Stark character (you know, ten years ago Favreau could have played Stark) and had shown clear interest in sequels and spin-off’s including a mega blockbuster Avengers movie.

Losing Favreau now would have been the kind of jolt of losing Richard Donner on Superman II. Thankfully that hasn’t happened.

Thanks for visiting us at Obsessed With Film, we update several times a day, so if you haven't done so yet you may want to subscribe to our RSS feed. You can also sign up to receive updates via e-mail.

July 10th, 2008 by Matt Holmes 5 comments

Marvel to dump Jon Favreau from IRON MAN 2?

Astonishingly, the rumor which now looks to be completely 100% true is that despite Jon Favreau almost single handily taking a B list Marvel superhero into the upper echelons of the Spider-Man and X-Men blockbusters and in the process making over $530 million worldwide at the box office alone, the studio are reluctant to pay the director his big salary for a sequel.

Can you believe that? Astonishing. The blame has squarely been branded on the head of David Maisel, the head chairman of Marvel Studio’s who many are calling “too cheap” to pay Favreau a fair sum. I mean after all, if Favreau has an awful lot to do with the franchise being in the strong position it’s in right now.

jon_favreau_iron_man_movie_image.jpg

The story comes originally from IESB but has since been backed up by AICN. This looks to be a serious problem and the lockdown in negotiations is undoubtedly why Marvel have not contacted the director in a few weeks and why Favreau recently stated that the 2010 release date was unrealistic.

The understanding is that Maisel doesn’t wanna pay Paramount the huge salaries that the likes of Brett Ratner and Michael Bay have gotten in the past and he believes that now the franchise is set on it’s feat, he could bring anyone to that director’s chair and the result would be the same… an uber popular movie that makes them a fortune.

Right as he may be, there are also more factors at stake. If a new director comes in and the movie bombs… that’s costly not just for future Iron Man films but for future cross-over movies and the universe you are finally starting to put together. Secondly… would Favreau’s good friends Robert Downey Jr. or Terrence Howard be so comfortable carrying on the series without him? Lose them, you lost your franchise.

Can you imagine if Warner Bros. handed asked Christopher Nolan to come back and direct The Dark Knight? Can you imagine if Sam Raimi had been dumped on Spider-Man after the first film?

I can be a pretty stubborn guy but Maisel right now needs to leave that behind and take a real long look at himself in the mirror. Pay up, Favreau deserves so much more than just a salary, he should have a golden ticket at Marvel for what he has done with Iron Man. Don’t screw things up already when everything was looking so rosy with your future plans!

June 11th, 2008 by Matt Holmes 4 comments

Jon Favreau says currrent IRON MAN 2 release date is “unrealistic”

Director Jon Favreau tells fans on his Myspace that contrary to what Terrence Howard said this week, filming will not be ready to begin in March on Iron Man 2 and that he is concerned that the April 2010 release date branded out by Paramount/Marvel is too “unrealistic”.

favreau-robert.png

It’s been five weeks since the one and only phone call my reps have gotten from Marvel. I know their hands are full with the Hulk and I’m sure they will get into it shortly, as they tell me they intend to. I ran into the Marvel guys at the Hulk premiere and everyone sounded eager to get to work on IM2.

I am concerned, however, about the announced release date of April 2010. Neither Robert nor I were consulted about this and we are both concerned about how realistic the date is in light of the fact that we have no script, story or even writers hired yet. This genre of movie is best when it is done thoughtfully and with plenty of preparation. It might be better to follow the BB/DK, X/X2 three year release pattern than to scramble for a date. It is difficult because there are no Marvel 09 releases and they need product, but I also think we owe it to the fans to have a great version of IM2 and, at this point, we would have less time to make it than the first one.

He answers a few more questions which you can read HERE but it’s openly obvious that they have no script and have barely sat down to discuss a sequel since the movie opened six weeks ago.

I’m sure these comments won’t go down well with Marvel. They very much want the sequel to be done by April 2010 otherwise it could disrupt their plans for the Thor, Captain America and then Avengers movie which are all tightly scheduled around each other.

source - coming soon

June 10th, 2008 by Matt Holmes 5 comments

IRON MAN 2 films in March 09

Terrence Howard, who should hopefully have far much more to do in the sequel has told Military.com that he is expected to turn up for filming to Iron Man 2 at Paramount next March.

The movie is scheduled for a release on April 30th 2010.

070502-f-4335c-111.jpg

I would expect everyone who survived the last movie to be back and also director Jon Favreau. The original movie is currently sitting comfortably on $288 million domestic and $530 million worldwide.

source - coming soon

June 9th, 2008 by Matt Holmes no comments

Marvel tease us over SPIDERMAN, THOR, IRON MAN, HULK, AVENGERS…

Marvel Studio’s is an exciting company to follow right now as they attempt to carve out the characters that they hope to build a universe around that can keep delivering Iron Man like numbers box office numbers for the next decade and even beyond.

As DC continue to debate, dither and quite simply fail over bringing their superheroes to the big screen that are outside of the big two, Marvel are pushing ahead with at least two movies a year and are making fortune after fortune.

440px-newavengers442.jpg

Slight gloating but more to tease and keep us informed about their future, Marvel released a press release this morning indicating their future plans…

  • April 30th 2010 - IRON MAN 2 (the movie will also introduce Thor according to the press release)
  • June 4th 2010 - THOR (Matthew Vaughn directing)
  • May 6th 2011 - THE FIRST AVENGER: CAPTAIN AMERICA (working title - which hints that Cap will be introduced in a slightly different manner to others)
  • July 2011 - THE AVENGERS (Hulk, Iron Man, Cap America, Thor, Nick Fury (and rest of S.H.I.E.L.D)… possibly/probably more!

Edgar Wright’s adaptation of Ant-Man is also still in development but no release date is attached as Wright has several projects he is considering as his next feature.

On the Hulk franchise the answer was “we are definitely planning more” which I translate as “we’ll wait and see how much money we pump into the sequel after the first movie has performed”. I’m sure they want to keep the character going though because they want him for The Avengers team-up eventually.

On the Spidey front (which remember is Columbia/Sony’s cinematic character) the answer was that it’s still in development and that they are excited about it continuing. Last we heard James Vanderbilt (Zodiac) was scribing and that Sam Raimi wasn’t going to commit until he had read the completed script.

Exciting times ahead then folks. Marvel are doing everything the right way as of right now and if they keep building these characters and turning in productions as of high quality as Iron Man then they will be the studio to watch over the next four or five years. Hopefully Jon Favreau will be the man given the task to do The Avengers movie because I think he desires it most… and is the best suited for the role.

As for Cap… it’s going to be interesting to see who they cast and get to direct. I believe David Goyer either was or still is writing the screenplay so he may be given the nod to direct also. After how well Iron Man has performed with Robert Downey Jr on board, I also wouldn’t be surprised if they cast a big name for that part.

source - coming soon

May 5th, 2008 by Matt Holmes 10 comments

BOX OFFICE: IRON MAN blasts off with $104 million domestic, $200 million worldwide!

U.S. Box Office for weekend of May 2nd - May 4th 2008

1   Iron Man (2008) $101M $104M
2   Made of Honor (2008) $15.5M $15.5M
3   Baby Mama (2008) $10.3M $32.3M
4   Forgetting Sarah Marshall (2008) $6.13M $44.8M
5   Harold & Kumar Escape from Guantanamo Bay (2008) $6.01M $25.3M
6   The Forbidden Kingdom (2008) $4.2M $45.1M
7   Nim’s Island (2008) $2.75M $42.5M
8   Prom Night (2008) $2.5M $41.4M
9   21 (2008) $2.1M $79.1M
10   88 Minutes (2007) $1.6M $15.4M

Iron Man has really been the perfect production for Marvel. A hassle free shoot, a great cast which came together for director Jon Favreau, critical acclaim, fanboy acclaim and now some real box office gold to boot.

The film which played at over 4,000 screens took home just over $100 million during it’s opening weekend, which totals to $104 million if you count the Thursday openings. It’s the 10th highest grossing opening of all time, a massive achievement for a non-sequel and is 60% higher than the usual Marvel film taking.

It’s worldwide total after 5 days is said to be an incredible $201 million, which is reported to be just under the amount it cost to film, market and distribute. And thanks to Robert Downey Jr, Jon Favreau and the rest of team on the film.. it’s pushed Iron Man a slightly lesser well known superhero into the cinematic echelons of the A-listers Spider-Man, Superman, Batman and X-Men.

475_iron_man_080502.jpg

As if anyone cares about the rest of the weekend but anyway, the wedding themed comedy Maid of Honor grossed a mediocre $15.5 million, well short of it’s over blown $40 million production. Unlike the similar themed 27 Dresses, this one didn’t quite carry the strong female lead and was actually more from the guy’s point of view with Patrick Dempsey actually the lead. Add to that, Michelle Monaghan wasn’t coming off an uber popular comedy like Katherine Heigl and at the end of the day the target audience (women) quite like Robert Downey Jr too… so I’m sure they were easily led by their boyfriends into seeing Iron Man.

madeofhonorgf.jpg

Elsewhere, there were huge drops for Baby Mama, The Forbidden Kingdom (which is falling RAPIDLY after the opening fanboy attendance) and the sequel to Harold and Kumar. Nothing it seems could stop the juggernaut that was Iron Man.

source - box office mojo

May 5th, 2008 by Matt Holmes 4 comments

IRON MAN - Ray’s Review!

iron_man_ver3reviewposter.jpgDirected by: Jon Favreau

Written by: Mark Fergus, Hawk Ostby, Art Marcum, Matt Holloway

Based on the classic Marvel characters created by Stan Lee, Don Heck, Larry Lieber, Jack Kirby

Starring: Robert Downey Jr, Terrence Howard, Jeff Bridges, Gwyneth Paltrow, Leslie Bibb, Shaun Toub, Faran Tahir, Bill Smitrovich, Clark Gregg, Jon Favreau, Stan Lee, Paul Bettany (voice)

Distributed by Paramount Pictures but the first fully financed movie from Marvel Studio’s

Film is released worldwide this week (April 30 - May 2nd 2008)… check your local cinema for exact date & time of first showings.

Review by Ray DeRousse

★★★★☆

Comic books usually have two problems inherent in their adaptations into films: they lack a certain believability, and they require origin stories that usually bore the hell out of everyone. As action film fans, we flock like lemmings to the theater, only to witness such snooze-inducing and incredulous nonsense like The Fantastic Four, Hulk, or Catwoman. Even certain fairly successful ones like the first X-Men movie had a difficult time setting up the franchise without coming off silly.

The ones that work - Superman, and although I’m not much of a fan, Spiderman - manage a fair amount of action and human drama that creates a solid and engaging story.

And now we can add a new standard bearer to the class of greatest comic book films of all time: Iron Man.

The film chronicles a billionaire genius weapons inventor named Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.), who is kidnapped during an impressive weapons display in Afghanistan. To escape his captors, he secretly builds a metal exoskeleton armed to the hilt. Once free, he dedicates his life to perfecting this suit and fighting the very militaristic evils he previously caused. Despite being aptly aided by his witty assistant Pepper Potts (Gwyneth Paltrow), his greatest villain exists right under his nose in the form of his company’s CEO, Obadiah Stane (Jeff Bridges).

This film leaps to the head of the class simply due to its stunning cast. Robert Downey Jr. deserves every single penny he will ever make from this franchise due to his legendary transformation into Tony Stark. Slick, self-absorbed, and snarky, Stark is a character Downey was born to play, and he does not disappoint. From the opening seconds, Downey commands the screen with his effortless charm and limitless sense of comic timing.

Many fans of the comic books howled when Paltrow was cast as Pepper Potts, yet this might be the most appealing Paltrow has ever been in a film. She plays Potts as a vulnerable woman beneath a cool, confident shell, the perfect foil for Stark’s constant cockiness. The real revelation in this film - aside from Downey, of course - is Jeff Bridges as Stane. He nearly engulfs the film with his ominous presence, his voice oozing menace.

Here, for once, we have a terrific cast in service to a terrific story. The best comic book movies contain sly commentaries on the world around us. IRON MAN is no different. It touches on many important themes, such as the importance of one’s work in life, the meaning of true terrorism, and the corruption and emptiness of power and material pursuit. Stark is a middle-aged man - not some teeny-bopper - and he faces his accomplishments with a maturity that is sorely lacking from films of this sort. His retreat from his former lifestyle forms the dramatic heart of this film, causing us to root for this lost man’s redemption.

His redemption, however, does not come easily. Blown up, sewn together, tortured, half-dead, and beaten to a pulp, Stark finds himself in the middle of several stunning and ball-busting action sequences. One thing is for certain - this film will rev you up. Accompanied by AC/DC and Iron Maiden rocking over the soundtrack, Iron Man destroys everything in his path. Particularly impressive is a mid-movie rescue of families in Afghanistan who are being tortured by terrorists. Director Jon Favreau keeps the action steady, easily dissected, and humorous.

Beyond all of the glorious action sequences, special effects, and brilliant character work, this film has a lot of heart. Running gags and cute, snappy wordplay keep audiences engaged. And if that’s not enough, the film is also loaded to the very brim with hot cars, impressive gadgetry, and gorgeous women. This might be the most masculine superhero movie ever made, and it is a welcome sight at the multiplex.

I cannot say enough about this flick. If not for the original Superman or X-Men 2, I might easily put this at the very top of my favorite comic book films. As it stands, it’s a toss up. I loved this damn movie!!!

May 2nd, 2008 by Ray DeRousse 5 comments

IRON MAN - Matt Holmes review!

iron_man_ver3reviewposter.jpgDirected by: Jon Favreau

Written by: Mark Fergus, Hawk Ostby, Art Marcum, Matt Holloway

Based on the classic Marvel characters created by Stan Lee, Don Heck, Larry Lieber, Jack Kirby

Starring: Robert Downey Jr, Terrence Howard, Jeff Bridges, Gwyneth Paltrow, Leslie Bibb, Shaun Toub, Faran Tahir, Bill Smitrovich, Clark Gregg, Jon Favreau, Stan Lee, Paul Bettany (voice)

Distributed by Paramount Pictures but the first fully financed movie from Marvel Studio’s

Film is released worldwide this week (April 30 - May 2nd 2008)… check your local cinema for exact date & time of first showings.

Review by Matt Holmes

★★★½☆

There’s a moment in Iron Man when Tony Stark takes flight to the sky’s in full control of his faithfully adapted red and gold suit, looking way more convincing in the air than the ridiculous amount of money spent by rival studio Warner Brothers on their Superman character two years ago that I began to think - isn’t it great to see how far comic book movies have come in the last ten years.

Memories have soon began to fade of 20th Century Fox and their rather tepid first attempt at the X-Men franchise, not quite sure how it was going to perform despite some big name casts. They were adamant and Bryan Singer certainly complied - in grounding the film down in reality as much as humanely possible which of course meant a travesty when the suits turned up on screen and they all looked the same. Lame black all around and the characters lost much of the personality that their own individual attire had given them for years in the printed and animated form.

Fast forward to 2008, comic books have never been this popular for such a long time - adults are coming back to the medium and it’s no doubt in some part due to this terrific cinematic movement that has ruled this decade of film. By the screening I saw tonight folks - we have come an extremely long way. Iron Man will rival Spider-Man 2 as the most faithfully adapted superhero film of all time.

Everything is here that fans of the comic have come to enjoy.

The perfectly cast (not just because of his off screen persona… but also how this has played into and often heightened his on screen roles), cocky, womanising, playful, smart, witty and insanely watchable Robert Downey Jr is a revelation as billionaire playboy Tony Stark who believes he is promoting peace by creating weapons which stroke fear into the rest of the world because they only needed to be fired once to cause ultimate destruction and are not created to be left on the shelf. “Worked pretty well so far” for the U.S. Stark says - we have a comic book movie here with some political intentions on it’s mind and one that is well aware of it’s country’s reputation in the world.

Iron Man, maybe in part down to it’s older and more experienced cast like a certain Batman Begins - feels much more adult than any Marvel superhero that has so far made into on screen with the possible exception of The Punisher which went a little too dark. It’s attempt at socio-political issues (which is actually something extremely faithful to Stan Lee’s original vision) is commended and the plot that isn’t necessarily about saving the world but has more to do with the war on terror - actually makes a refreshing change. As does a romance between a superhero and the main female lead which actually has sparks.

Their chemistry is super red hot - matching Gwyneth Paltrow’s fine hairdo as loyal assistant Pepper Potts. I actually hated her casting the first time it was mentioned but to her credit, she gives her most energetic and enjoyable performance in years. You feel something for them here and you care about their relationship, though her part may be slightly under-written.

As was Terrence Howard’s role as good pal Jim Rhodes - who in this movie acts as the go between for Stark and U.S. military, allowing him to get away with things normal people just won’t be able to do. More of him next time would be great but it seems like his character is in it for the long haul.

As for the villain, I enjoyed much of what Jeff Bridges did when he was playing the warm-hearted friend and mentor to Tony and as we have seen in the past he makes a terrific bad guy but as soon as he puts on the suit he kinda bores ya. But he’s a good first villain - similar kind of arc to Liam Neeson’s part in Begins and although hardly memorable - it is difficult to stand above this film’s lead.

So it’s pretty kick ass over all. The action sequences for the most part are terrific - it manages to fulfil all the summer blockbuster criteria of big explosions, gadgets and the like with the special effects staying extremely high with very little moments of disappointment.

Iron Man is the movie Michael Bay tried or maybe should have tried a lot harder to make with the Transformers. It’s well written, doesn’t fully insult your intelligence, it’s lauded with great jokes and one-liners but not the “let’s creep around so the parents can’t see us” kind and is made by a director who understands this material - and knows exactly what he is doing.

Director Jon Favreau who is really making a big step up from his usual fare here (Elf, Zathura, Swingers) directs his first big-budget action vehicle and does it very well and he should be extremely proud of his work here. There’s more talented and experienced directors who have attempted this genre and haven’t been as successful as Favreau. His love for the character and his undeniable high production values and commitment in creating a unique and interesting feel for Tony Stark and his world is very much to the film’s huge benefit. He knows what the fans want and for the most part he has delivered it.

There are plenty of problems to be hard here for sure. As is beginning to become the norm with comic book movies, the third act is absolutely terrible. It feels majorly rushed, never seems to run at a coherent pace and when the big battle comes at the end you have dialogue and awkwardness which sometimes suggests why a literal adaptation of a comic book page is not the way to go.

I think this will come apparent from more frequent viewings but 2/3rd’s of the flick are great. 85% of the movie rules.

It was a brave move when Marvel decided to stop letting other studio’s play with their characters and to start fully financing the movies themselves but it has paid off big time here. This is a proper comic book film which is one of the best to watch as an adult. There’s so much potential for this series of films and the universe Marvel is creating if they continue making films as loud and brass as this.

This is very much a Robert Downey Jr vehicle and it’s great to see him fully blown into the spotlight here. This is an extremely bold and confident start from Marvel and I’m very much excited to see where this is taken. We get hints to lots of future things here… including mentions of a certain organisation and maybe next time we shall get a look at War Machine. “Next time baby, next time” says Jim Rhodes 2/3rd’s into the movie.

And I would be happy to see it. Bring on the sequel!

May 1st, 2008 by Matt Holmes 4 comments

IRON MAN - Michael Edwards Review!

iron_man_ver3reviewposter.jpgDirected by: Jon Favreau

Written by: Mark Fergus, Hawk Ostby, Art Marcum, Matt Holloway

Based on the classic Marvel characters created by Stan Lee, Don Heck, Larry Lieber, Jack Kirby

Starring: Robert Downey Jr, Terrence Howard, Jeff Bridges, Gwyneth Paltrow, Leslie Bibb, Shaun Toub, Faran Tahir, Bill Smitrovich, Clark Gregg, Jon Favreau, Stan Lee

Distributed by Paramount Pictures

Film is released worldwide this week (April 30 - May 2nd 2008)… check your local cinema for exact date & time of first showings.

Review by Michael Edwards

★★★★☆

I’ve long been thinking that Iron Man is an interesting comic book adaptation. Not quite up there with the fan bases of the illustrated megastars like those eclectic X-Men, kooky Fantastic Four or magnificent lone crusaders known as Superman, Spiderman and Batman but nonetheless an interestingly layered chap with conflicting personality traits and a few cool gadgets plus a wadge of cash to play with. In terms of the real names tied to the project we have Jon Favreau directing his first action film along with a host of big name celebs who are also, for the most part, action amateurs. Could it be a combination that leads to the kind of overly dialogue-driven origin film, but with a better selected cast to bear the burden? Well I say no! It’s somehow formed an amazingly satisfying Hollywood soup that left me hungering for more.

The backstory has been updated from the original by relocating the kidnap of weapons magnate and all-round business/technology genius Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr) to Afghanistan rather than Vietnam, and there are a few obvious tweaks to fit the Hollywood format but otherwise the opening tale remains pretty faithful. After his kidnap, Stark manages to build a massive metal suit that not only provides him armour but has an impressive arsenal too, armed with this he escapes his captors and destroys their weapons cache which, much to Stark’s concern, comes from his much beloved all-American arms company. On his return he renounces his lifestyle of boozing and womanising decides he doesn’t want to be involved in the tawdry business anymore, and instead develops his suit and goes off to right his company’s wrongs. But little does he know his father-figure and long term mentor is about to become a crazed villain bent on stealing his ideas and wreaking destruction who he must fight in order to prevent his new technology causing even more pain and devastation. And within all that there’s even a few obligatory cameos and inserted retro memorabilia for the hardcore fans out there.

The main thing you should’ve all realised by now is what a masterstroke the casting was. Robert Downey Jr as a wise guy playboy who is prone to drinking and womanising but gives it all up to live a decent life, Jeff Bridges as a deceptively warm-hearted, cuddly father figure who turns out to be a power hungry psycho. How can no-one have noticed how perfect this is before! Thank god somebody finally had the guts to move away from the pitiful selection of typecast action heroes and resist the urge of wheeling out half dead relics from the 80’s to make their cash in the glitzy world of Hollywood. It really is refreshing.

In terms of the action sequences, and let’s face it that’s what’s make-or-break for a comic book franchise, (need I hold up the first yawn fest that was the first Fantastic Four movie as evidence?), those of you who think Transformers was the best movie ever may suggest that there could have been more but I personally think the balance was just right. The rapid pace and surplus of explosions and combat in the opening 15 minutes whets the appetite, and we are kept ticking over by the occasional skirmish or comedic explosion during the fine-tuning of Iron Man’s suit as the unfolding of the backstory of the eponymous hero unfolds, and there are a few large scale fights in which the special effects and CGI more than holds its own against the big boys. Iron Man fights terrorists, fighter jets and bigger mechanical suits with equal gusto, allowing us to sit back and enjoy the visual orgy of crunching metal, screaming missiles and blistering explosions with glee.

My biggest concern is that people have become too bogged down in looking at these first movies about a comic book character as ‘origin movies’ designed to set-up a franchise, but I think Iron Man holds up as a film in it’s own right and still managed to leave you hoping that there will be more. It beats the hell out of all the Spider-Man films, makes Superman look like a bland little goody goody, and has the Fantastic Four feeling all embarrassed about how boring and stupid they look. In the last 10 years or so I’d say only the X-Men have had more to offer as a comic book adaptation. Buy hey, second best isn’t bad!

April 29th, 2008 by Michael Edwards 5 comments

IRON MAN clip: “Run before you can walk”

There’s a really cool clip for Iron Man over at the film’s official website, showcasing part of the scene “Run Before You Can Walk”.

iron-man-clip.png

It’s actually pretty neat and hopefully shows that Jon Favreau is going to keep us close to Robert Downey Jr’s character as we see his journey from Tony Stark into Iron Man, which is a great thing because the character can sometimes not be that likeable.

It’s a non-spoiler clip and will hardly ruin the film for you so it’s well worth a look.

CLICK HERE TO SEE RUN BEFORE YOU CAN WALK

April 8th, 2008 by Matt Holmes 3 comments